Roofers in Aylmer
7 roofers in Aylmer with multi-platform trust scores.
Loading roofers...
Who is the best roofer in Aylmer, Ontario?
The highest-scoring roofers in Aylmer on ProScore are Elgin Roofing (69/100), Masterpiece Metal Roofing (63/100) and New Face Metal Roofing (61/100). ProScore has scored 7 roofers in Aylmer across 10+ data sources and 20+ trust signals. None of the 7 meet the Trusted-tier (70+) threshold yet.
Star ratings alone do not separate them: 6 of the 7 average 4.5 stars or higher on Google, but none reach Trusted (70+). ProScore also weighs government licensing where it applies, WSIB coverage, ratings on other platforms and what customers say in their reviews.
Trust scores last computed between October 13, 2026 and October 24, 2026.
Which roofers in Aylmer score highest?
All 7 scored roofers in Aylmer, ranked by ProScore.
ProScore scores 7 roofers in Aylmer, and their average score is 60 out of 100. 3 are registered with WSIB. 7 have Google reviews on file — 378 reviews in total, and 2 carry a Better Business Bureau rating.
Elgin Roofing operates on weekdays out of Aylmer and has wheelchair-accessible parking on site.
Elgin Roofing ranks 1st of the 7 roofers ProScore scores in Aylmer, holding a ProScore of 69 out of 100 (Good tier). Its score draws on 256 Google reviews averaging 4.9 out of 5 and a Better Business Bureau rating of A+. Public records show it is registered with WSIB.
Masterpiece Metal Roofing handles metal roofing work in Aylmer and completes jobs with careful attention to workmanship and site cleanup, with a track record of finishing ahead of schedule and maintaining professional, courteous service throughout.
Masterpiece Metal Roofing ranks 2nd of the 7 roofers ProScore scores in Aylmer, holding a ProScore of 63 out of 100 (Good tier). Its score draws on 59 Google reviews averaging 5.0 out of 5.
New Face Metal Roofing operates seven days a week and works on site in Aylmer, Ontario.
New Face Metal Roofing ranks 3rd of the 7 roofers ProScore scores in Aylmer, holding a ProScore of 61 out of 100 (Good tier). Its score draws on 20 Google reviews averaging 4.8 out of 5.
Miller Exteriors Inc. is a roofing contractor based in Aylmer, Ontario, working on site during weekday hours. Free and wheelchair-accessible parking is available.
The ProScore for Miller Exteriors Inc. draws on 8 Google reviews averaging 5.0 out of 5.
The ProScore for Landmark Roofing - Metal Roofing Expert in Straffordville draws on 14 Google reviews averaging 5.0 out of 5.
The ProScore for 5 Star Steel draws on 18 Google reviews averaging 4.8 out of 5. Public records show 5 Star Steel is registered with WSIB.
Upright Construction Inc. operates weekdays as a roofer based in Aylmer, Ontario, with wheelchair-accessible parking available.
The ProScore for Upright Construction Inc. draws on 3 Google reviews averaging 4.3 out of 5 and a Better Business Bureau rating of A+. Public records show Upright Construction Inc. is registered with WSIB.
How is a roofer's ProScore calculated?
Every roofer in Aylmer is evaluated across four pillars: Reputation (ratings across multiple platforms), Verification (government licensing where it applies and WSIB), Transparency (online presence and profile completeness), and Sentiment (AI analysis of customer reviews). The result is a ProScore from 0 to 100.
Read the full methodology →Who are the top 3 roofers in Aylmer?
Browse all roofers in Aylmer →What else should I check before hiring roofers in Aylmer?
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the best roofer in Aylmer?
Elgin Roofing has the highest ProScore (69/100) among 7 roofers in Aylmer, Ontario. Rankings are based on ProScore, which evaluates ratings, government licensing where it applies, WSIB coverage, and AI-analyzed customer sentiment.
How do I find a trustworthy roofer in Aylmer?
Look for roofers with verified active WSIB coverage, and consistent ratings across multiple platforms. ProScore aggregates these signals into a single score from 0-100. In Aylmer, 0 roofers hold Elite-tier ProScores (81+), 0 are Trusted-tier (70+), and 6 are Good-tier (54+).
Are roofers in Aylmer licensed?
Ontario has no provincial licence for roofers. Ask for proof of WSIB coverage and liability insurance, and for any business licence your municipality requires. Of the top 7 roofers in Aylmer by ProScore, 3 are registered with WSIB according to ProScore’s records.
How many roofers has ProScore scored in Aylmer?
ProScore has scored 7 roofers in Aylmer, Ontario. Each provider is evaluated using 10+ data sources, 20+ trust signals, and AI-analyzed customer reviews. Trust scores last computed between October 13, 2026 and October 24, 2026.
What's the ProScore distribution among roofers in Aylmer?
Among 7 roofers in Aylmer, Ontario: 0 are Elite-tier (81+), 0 are Trusted-tier (70+), and 6 are Good-tier (54+). Together they average a ProScore of 60/100, with Elgin Roofing leading at 69/100.
Roofers near Aylmer
The nearest Ontario cities with a ProScore page for this trade — a pro based nearby may cover your area.
Other trades in Aylmer
Other trades with a ProScore page in Aylmer, with the number of scored pros in each.